The Hidden Cost of Washington’s Tariff Whiplash
Written by Scott R. Siler
The following excerpt is from "The Hidden Cost of Washington's Tariff Whiplash" on The U.S. Chamber of Commerce Global Intelligence Desk Substack and was written by S4GEO Advisory Board member, Scott Siler.
A tariff is a cost. Uncertainty is something else entirely.
Since President Trump announced sweeping global tariffs in April 2025, companies have scrambled to reprice products, renegotiate contracts, and reroute orders. It’s expensive, but it’s manageable. Businesses know how to deal with higher costs. The bigger struggle is: Will these same costs even exist next quarter?
Consider a company deciding whether to shift production out of China, sign a long-term supply contract, or build a new factory. A 10% tariff might justify the investment. But what if that tariff disappears next month? Or doubles? Or gets struck down by a court?
The problem isn’t simply what tariffs cost today. It’s the business decisions that cannot be made because it’s incredibly difficult to know what they’ll cost tomorrow. And that uncertainty comes with a considerable price tag.
The International Chamber of Commerce and Oxford Economics estimate that policy uncertainty reduced business investment across ten major economies by $202 billion in 2025, including roughly $74 billion in the United States. That’s investment delayed or forgone, with consequences for factories, hiring, and future growth.
Even now the refunds flowing back to businesses cannot make them whole. The government can return the duties collected, but it cannot remedy the opportunity cost of waiting: The inventory that sat, the hires that were delayed, the expansions that were shelved.
Consider the tariff whiplash of 2026. On February 20, the Supreme Court ruled that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) did not authorize President Trump’s tariff policy, invalidating the duties imposed under it in 2025.
That same day, the administration imposed a temporary 10% global tariff under a different statute, Section 122. In May, the Court of International Trade ruled against the tariff in a limited decision that was stayed on appeal. The tariff expired on July 24.
Soon afterward, new duties of 10% to 12.5% on goods from 60 economies took effect under Section 301, the culmination of a 90-day investigation. Those duties are now being challenged in court by 25 states and several small importers.
Three legal authorities in five months. Three different sets of rules. And businesses were expected to make investment decisions that could take years to pay off.
And the pattern continues. The U.S.–China understanding that was due to expire on November 10th has been extended to January 10th, with no firm indication of what follows. The U.S. Mexico Canada Agreement (USMCA), rather than being renewed, has moved to annual reviews.
Every tariff rate on the books now carries an unspoken qualification: “for now”.
This exposes a fundamental mismatch. Washington operates on political and legal timelines. Businesses operate on investment timelines. A court can invalidate a tariff overnight. A manufacturer cannot relocate a factory overnight.
That is why tariff uncertainty is so difficult to manage. A company can neither confidently influence whether a policy survives nor reliably predict it. The instinct is to forecast more intensely, scouring every signal from Washington. Yet the outcome hinges on courts, negotiations, and political calculations that are often opaque.
The more useful exercise is to stop asking whether a policy will last and start measuring what it would mean if it did not. That begins with exposure.
Most firms know their total tariff bill, but how many know which product lines a change in either direction would break? Understanding this helps a company identify its thresholds: the rate at which a product stops making economic sense and would need to be repriced, resourced, or dropped.
“Tariffs might change” is not something a management team can act on. But managers can set parameters: “Above 18%, this line requires a decision.”
Then there is time. How long would it take to shift a supplier, reprice a contract, or pull back an order? A business that can adjust in six weeks faces a very different risk from one that needs six months, even at the same tariff rate.
And because time can be bought - qualifying a second supplier, adding a tariff-adjustment clause, or accepting smaller minimum orders - the cost of that flexibility can be weighed against the exposure it covers.
No Accounting for Washington
None of this requires knowing what Washington will do. It requires knowing the business, which is something every company can do.
The final step is deciding in advance. A threshold is only useful if someone has agreed what happens when it is crossed. Writing those decisions down, naming who makes the call, and revisiting the numbers before policy gets tested, whether through truce expirations, court rulings, or trade reviews, turns a policy shift into the execution of a plan rather than the start of a debate. It also argues for caution before restructuring around any single tariff rate.
A move that only works if today’s tariff survives is a bet on continuity that no one can underwrite.
No business can control what Washington does next. It cannot guarantee that a tariff will survive a court challenge, a trade negotiation, or the next policy announcement. But it can know what
those changes would mean for its operations. It can establish the thresholds that trigger decisions, build flexibility into its supply chains, and decide in advance how to respond.
The companies that navigate this period best won’t necessarily be those that correctly predict Washington’s next move. They’ll be the ones that don’t need to.
Scott Siler is a geopolitical strategist and the founder of Exergy International ([LINKSHIELD PROTECTED]original-text:d3d3LmV4ZXJneWludGwuY29t;), a consultancy specializing in political risk advisory and geopolitical consulting services. His views are not necessarily those of the U.S. Chamber, though the Global Intelligence Desk hopes readers will find his take as valuable as we do.